AIRmail 10-19-26
Key Takeaways:
● McNulty Adds Veneto Classic
● Carapaz Moves to NSN as EF Slims Down
● Does Dodger Collapse Weaken Salary Cap Argument?
● Who Owns Athlete Biometric Data?
● Rapid Progress for Athletes Unlimited
● Hot Takes: “Air bags” for Cyclists; Continuing Saudi Sports Pull Back
Freshly-crowned World Champion Brandon McNulty closed his season with a strong attack on the Veneto Classic’s steep climbs on Sunday to grab a definitive solo win, continuing a three-year streak where the reigning world champion has won a race in the same season right after taking the title. Outside of lifting a massive amount of pressure off his shoulders, the win underlines the fact that McNulty didn’t simply get lucky in Montréal, but that he has a unique level of raw physical class enabling him to ride clear of almost everyone in the peloton. With the win capping a strong final stretch of racing in Italy since Montréal, where he has looked like a changed rider, look for the American to have a breakout 2027. He has evolved from a capable rider who quietly finishes inside the top 10 in race win rankings (like he did in 2024), to one at the front of nearly every major race he enters.
Richard Carapaz’s move to NSN on a deal through 2029 was officially confirmed, thus ending his four seasons at EF Education-EasyPost a bit early. The move may look like a transfer, but it’s actually a budget story – with EF’s ownership having reportedly cut a sizable portion from the team’s budget in an attempt to limit their own exposure and to bring on additional co-sponsorship. As a result, EF is said to have told Carapaz it could no longer honor his contract, which let him leave without a transfer fee, allowing NSN to pick him up at a reported €2.5 million per season, a relative bargain for a multi-Tour de France stage winner with the 12th-most grand tour stage wins among active riders. Additionally, Carapaz is the rarer rider capable of contending for the GC without a full team built around him. Meanwhile, EF is left with a massive hole to fill in its stage-racing program and apparently not much money to do so. This may explain the team’s “money-ball “acquisition of Tao Geoghegan Hart, the 2020 Giro d’Italia winner who hasn’t finished inside the top ten of a Grand Tour in six seasons.
Few teams had a worse week than Picnic PostNL, with a joint investigation by NOS Sport and In de Waaier, built on interviews with 71 current and former staff and riders that paints a vivid picture of a culture of fear, extreme control, and horrid results. Former coach Adriaan Helmantel called it a dictatorship, with some accounts describing distress severe enough that they considered harming themselves. Even if the team can mount a deft counter, at this point its problems likely outweigh any potential solutions. As we mentioned last week, they currently sit at an absurdly low 30th in the UCI team rankings, with 12 second-division teams above them and only a one-year WorldTour license in hand. Should their license be renewed for 2027 – which isn’t a given considering the team’s reported €19.5m losses over the last three years – it is worth asking if the team can realistically recruit enough firepower to stave off eventual relegation. Beyond that, the question looms of whether the team’s structure and methodology of total management control is simply out-of-date in a modern-era where athletes have never had more control over their own brand and messaging.
The Milwaukee Brewers’ unexpected sweep of the world champion L.A. Dodgers has the sports world abuzz – and the decisive victory could turn out to be an interesting factor as Major League Baseball moves towards renegotiating its labor agreement. A key component of the upcoming negotiations – similar to the UCI’s proposed reform of cycling – is the owners’ push for a salary cap. Milwaukee is the league’s smallest market and ranking 19th in terms of player payroll, but they drubbed the Dodgers who sit at the very top of both rankings. Put concisely: the Dodgers’ decisive loss doesn’t lend much support to team owners’ claims that a salary cap is critical to maintain a competitive, level playing field. (Further undercutting that argument is the fact that the other league championship features the Cleveland Guardians and Tampa Bay Rays – the sport’s second and fourth smallest payrolls respectively.)
Baseball’s Dodgers are comparable to pro cycling’s UAE Emirates XRG team – both clubs boast their sport’s largest budgets, and contain similar rosters full of high-priced and high-profile athletes like Shohei Ohtani and Tadej Pogacar. Put in rough cycling terms – at least on a comparative salary basis – last week’s events were akin to the afore-mentioned Picnic Post-NL team sweeping all of the grand tours next year. But as both baseball and professional cycling move towards consideration of a possible salary cap to promote equitable competition, these baseball developments have thrown a fly in the ointment. It poses the perennial question: do richer teams actually dominate the sport. The evidence from baseball at least for this fall seems to be a resounding no. In cycling, the situation is far less clear. Even with the dominant Tadej Pogacar (and several of his teammates) out with injuries late in the season, the team still boasted other top victories with Brandon McNulty taking the worlds, and Isaac del Toro proving himself as a top contender of the future in various races. The evidence from cycling for a salary cap is still a definite “yes.”
As we’ve pointed out numerous times in the past, money isn’t everything. Some small-budget teams garner big wins now and then – and superb recruitment, development, management and strategy can sometimes out-perform big budgets. However, there’s no doubt that over the long term and on average more money helps to generate more wins. Despite last week’s evidence to the contrary, the MLB owners are likely to double-down on the salary cap issue and set a collision course with their labor force, which has enjoyed some 40 years of rising salaries. As it stands, it looks like that the owners will lock out the players in December, when the current bargaining agreement expires. We have yet to see where cycling’s consideration of this contentious issue will go, but the evidence seems ever clearer that something needs to be done to level the playing field.
One of the most sought-after but contentious data sets in professional cycling is athlete biometric information, but the NBA might be laying the groundwork for how athlete information is used in the future. Pro cycling has been a standard bearer for wearable biometric capture devices going all the way back to Greg LeMond’s adoption of the first generation Seiko pulse-meter in 1985. Flash forward to the present day and riders are now outfitted with multiple wearables for constant health monitoring and training and in-race data capture. Arguably, too much of that data is made publicly available on commercial platforms like Strava. At various times, key race broadcasts have displayed rider heart rate and power numbers; however, the delivery and presentation of that data has been less than cohesive in the past due to inconsistent participation of the riders and teams, and unclear screen layout and explanation for the viewers.
The presentation side of biometrics is still evolving, but at a fundamental layer, legal ownership of the data and how it can be misused for a variety of ill intentions is driving a rethink on the playing field. Enter the NBA’s recent take on the topic, shared by league President Adam Silver. During a wider discussion of in-game wearable tech like referee wrist communicators, Silver noted that most players are already using devices 22 hours a day, but taking them off for competition. The reason is clear, as he pointed out: “If you could see a player was slowing down or something like that, they’re worried that that could get used in bargaining” to devalue earning power. In a wider view, that data could also be used for wagering and prediction market contracts based on player performance, and more generally make players’ personal health data publicly available. Thus, any future data use will have to be negotiated with the NBA Players Association, and given its high value, will likely command a high price tag.
Cycling’s approach in this arena, either with the VELON teams providing the information or by voluntary contribution from non-aligned teams, may also need a rethink. First, the riders should investigate the legal and personal ramifications more closely; their data isn’t just part of a dashboard. It is also a personal record of performance that can be used against them in contract negotiations. And second, it may quickly force a reckoning of the current Joint Agreement to clearly define wearable data ownership and its value to the riders. While some international legal scholars view the data as public – that is, not intellectual property because the data points are captured as routine facts by an observation device – others define the data as protected health information privately owned by the individual. What is certain is that the riders, much like their professional counterparts in basketball, should think twice before opening a data door they won’t be able to close without the appropriate legal protections signed beforehand.
In roughly the same span of time that the UCI relaunched the Women’s WorldTour, Athletes Unlimited has rapidly built three successful women’s professional sports leagues. While its basketball teams are largely overshadowed by the WNBA, its volleyball and softball investments have grown rapidly. In particular, the softball league recently reported a 150% ratings increase on ESPN, a 110% increase in merchandise sales, and 25 game sellouts. The players are reportedly paid between $35,000 and $80,000 per season, with some star names earning more. However, these athletes aren’t waiting on change: on Tuesday last week, the players formally unionized as a first step to seeking a collective bargaining agreement with the league.
The newly formed AUSL Players Association cited the role that collective bargaining has played in accelerating the growth of basically every other professional sports league in existence. As we have pointed out ad nauseum for years now, men’s pro cycling has never developed any kind of real rider’s union – and in the big picture, the sport suffers because of that. However, women’s pro cycling occupies a very similar space as the AUSL: athletes in a growing license-based premier competitive system with the potential to force sports business evolution by collectively demanding strategic and financial shifts that benefit everyone in the sport’s ecosystem. Parallel to the men’s CPA “association,” the women’s sport has a similar, minor CPA-affiliated group although the The Cyclists’ Alliance sits in perhaps a stronger advocacy and support position. Whichever direction the women in pro cycling choose, real change will only happen when the athletes exercise solidarity and demand it.
Hot Takes:
- One item of interest in the on-going pro cycling safety debate may be the gradual development and acceptance of “air bags.” Although it may at first seem a little counter-intuitive or curious how such devices could work on a regular road bike, one Belgian company is now promoting a personal airbag designed to attach under any pair of bib shorts and sit flush under a jersey, and it just landed on Time Magazine’s best inventions list. It is basically a inflatable vest equipped with a proprietary CO2 canister and nine motion sensors. “When it detects a fall, the device quickly inflates around the rider’s neck and torso to cushion their impact.”
- Saudi Arabia’s withdrawal from the sports scene continues. The Kingdom announced that it would drop plans to build five new stadiums for the 2034 men’s World Cup; it previously withdrew from hosting the 2029 Asian Winter Games, cancelled its support for LIV Golf, and delayed a major tennis tournament. The country had already begun cutting back on its ambitious sports programs starting about a year ago, but that trend has accelerated with the U.S.-Iran war and the recent Houthi strikes on its major cities.



Worth adding that NBA players already won part of this fight at the table. The 2017 CBA barred teams from using wearable data in contract negotiations or in transactions like trades and waivers, with fines up to $250,000 for a violation. Silver's comment suggests players still worry about that fence holding. For cycling, it shows the order of operations: the clause has to exist before the data reaches broadcasts and betting feeds, and without a real union there's nobody to bargain for it. Is anyone at the CPA or The Cyclists' Alliance pushing for something similar?